The PACSMan Pontificates: Prepping for RSNA, Part 1

The PAC5Man Pontificates podcast cover featuring host Marlon Carrasco discussing AI, emerging imaging, and future technology

It sucks getting old. I can’t recall what I had for breakfast yesterday but can recall my first RSNA. There were three of us in a rented U-Haul van driving downtown Chicago around trying to find the famous Days Inn we got booked at. We got off at an exit that looked promising and I saw the words “Cabrini Towers” and thought it was an Italian neighborhood with someone who could help us. I couldn’t have been more wrong. The PAC5Man Pontificates podcast cover featuring host Marlon Carrasco discussing AI, emerging imaging, and future technology

Fast forward to today. Attending 38 of the past 42 RSNA’s got me a collection of press badges and a bunch of people clamoring to see who this year’s PACSMan Awards “winners” were. This year I became the capitalist I have always avoided being. I love writing it but frankly the $2,000 it cost me to attend RSNA is better spent towards my Caribbean Cruise this February instead so I am not planning on going. That may change but I doubt it. We’ll see.

It’s humbling to see the PACSMan Awards were ranked #1 of the most read stories on AuntMinnie back in 2004 and have been among the top three ever since. It tells me that people would rather hear Bruce Hornsby’s “The Way It Is” than that old hymn “How Great Thou Art”. Now that AI and the Cloud are the new PACS the “Positive Polly” hymns again seem to greatly outnumber  the “Realistic Ralphs” tunes I sing.  All I can do is hope is that someone throws a few coins and maybe a bill or two into the guitar case now and then after reading my affirmation of John 8:32 - “And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.”

Honesty

Early on in my career I found out honesty goes a long way at least with some people. I recall a meeting with the President of Kodak in the Fairmont Hotel in the late 1980’s. We chatted and after a bit he excused himself to use the rest room. The next thing I know his handlers were all around me saying “No one ever talked to him the way you did!!”  When he returned he said to me “I appreciate your openness. I never get a straight story from my people. They only say what they think I want to hear. You say it as you see it.” Forty years after hearing those words the politically incorrect PACSMan was born.

Irreverence and political correctness get a client nowhere. Over the years I have become much more diplomatic… well …..sorta…I still call it like I see it but now respect others' right to make decisions that that fly in the face of the factual information presented to them for consideration….  but hey, it’s all good in the hood.

I like that the Pope Francis was that way too -- he called it as he saw it. I thought about running for his vacant position (God rest his soul) but AI screened me out of contention. Another reason why I hate AI. That’s sad because I could at one time say the mass in Italian, Latin, and English and was even an altar boy from ages 6-13 so….I guess I was just slightly underqualified. Pope Leo XIV will have to do. He is a good old Chicago boy so maybe he can come bless the opening of RSNA next year. I still feel I would make a good pope even though the only words I remember in Italian some of the mass and those mom would not approve of….

Now not all the companies or facilities I worked with appreciated my candor and wisdom. Some just wanted to validate their own impressions. More than one client wanted just to be able to justify why they needed PACS -- any PACS, not the one that made the most sense for them. Nearly all had favorites before the game even started even though they might proclaim that everyone has a fair chance to win their business. 

That’s the way it still is as well. But over the years I’ve gotten smarter and become a capitalist -- I’ll take money to help you and you can choose whomever you want. I though about doing some work on the dark side but after reflecting on the few stints I had realized working full time in the commercial sector was not for someone as politically astute as I am. After all, why ask my opinion if you really aren’t interested in it. Silly me…

Asking the right questions

While most clients feel they know it all they eventually accept the fact that they don’t. The best clients also realize that none of us is as smart as all of us. Asking the right questions and getting the right answers gets them what they need. After all they are committing to a project that has to last almost a decade and making an investment that can cost them millions as well as their career if they are proven wrong. After 40+ years in the industry I am also proof that yes, you can teach an old dog new tricks.

These past few years I traversed the great divide that separates Cloud PACS from on-prem PACS…. or shall I say native vs. non-native Cloud PACS. It reminds me of native Americans vs. the European invaders. Evaluating Cloud PACS is completely different than looking at an on-prem solution. If you don’t ask the right questions you can be either scalped, lose a lot of wampum or both.

My latest engagement opened my eyes and the clients to how everything needs to be looked at closely. With some vendors, costs not stated up front added up to almost $1M over what we thought was the bottom line. “Why didn’t you tell me?” the client and I both asked. “Why didn’t you ask?” the vendor retorted.  I used to joke with my mom about my love life “Ask me no questions I’ll tell you no lies.” And so it is sadly with so many PACS today.

Doing PACS and AI right is about understanding what questions to ask so that when you get there you made the right choice -- with apologies to AT&T who were the wrong choice in PACS in the late 1980’s.

Nearly all vendors base their pricing on volume so when you hear prices like $2.25 a per study bantered about that may be their baseline for a moderate-volume site. Lower volumes costs more, higher a bit less. Now to be realistic take that cost and multiply it by at least 1.5. You may end up factoring $1M in upfront costs, sometimes less, often more. Then you come closer to the actual costs required just to say hello. It’s like buying a car. There are always dealer fees involved and this, that, and the other adding 15-25% to the base price.

Vendor checklists

To divert a buyer and help offset sticker shock many vendors have been offering checklists that help justify Cloud-native vs non-native PACS vs hybrid systems. These typically focus on five key areas -- architecture, deployment, scalability, and cost effectiveness. Others address things like downtime, installation, upfront cost, and image loading speed.

Native PACS has an advantage in several areas but you need to look closely to see if the stated advantages are applicable to your site. Take image loading speed as one example. One of the promoted benefits of Cloud-native is image retrieval speed using server-side rendering. This allows quick image loading without pre-fetching. If you are starting an archive from scratch with no prior studies the benefit here is crystal clear. But since nearly every site typically has over a decade of priors in a PACS archive or a VNA, pre-fetching is a reality.

Cost is a major consideration. You can migrate the images to the Cloud and do data normalization while you are at it but that typically adds $500K or more to the tab and 8-9 months to do it as well.

The second is even more of a challenge. When you were sold administration on the VNA with your last PACS it was sold as the very last archive you will ever need. Now vendors are saying if you don’t do the data migration and store everything in the Cloud you can pretty much kiss the advertised four nines of uptime (99.99%) goodbye. That is bound to raise a few eyebrows from the folks upstairs whom you are asking for millions to replace your PACS, relating to trusting you and the vendors both on what was said before.

Another of the benefits being promoted is auto scaling. This adjusts the capacity based on user load. That’s a great feature if you plan on a merger that increases your volume significantly but if it decreases you are typically stuck with the volume commitment you made early on. At the very least your stated per-study rate will stay the same for the balance of the contract term.

No one size fits all

No vendor is one size fits all. Some vendors are best for IDN’s, some for smaller health systems, some for teleradiology applications while others function best in an imaging center environment. Some vendors won’t consider a facility that does over 300K procedures while others won’t consider those who do less. Just look at their website and if all they show is one type of facility don’t believe they can do others without proof.

Maintenance costs and most interface costs are typically built into a software-as-a-service (SaaS) model. These usually are extra in a legacy PACS. Maintenance in a legacy system typically adds 15% of the list price and is included in a SaaS model. Interfaces are often covered in a SaaS model as well although they can be extra as well depending on what is being interfaced to if not part of the native PACS vendors package. Upgrades are typically included in a SaaS model where the cost is extra in an on-prem solution. However, both offer software updates at no charge

You may be also limited in choosing a cloud service provider (CSP). The vast majority of vendors use Amazon, Microsoft, or Google but other third-party providers have been used as well. Typically this is determined by the vendor. Certain CSP costs are absorbed by the end user as well although typically these are not significant- only the cost of connectivity to the cloud that are dependent on the distance to the access point can be high. Cloud archiving is also additional and can be very significant as well.

Almost every vendor has a six figure fixed cost for professional services. These cover everything related to getting a site up and running.  These include project management, installation, configuration, integration, training and pre/post go-live support and optimization. These are paid up front and cover everything related to being able to clinically accept the system.

AI can take up several articles so this will be addressed in part two. Stay tuned.

Michael J. Cannavo is known industry-wide as the PACSMan. After several decades as an independent PACS consultant, he worked as both a strategic accounts manager and solutions architect with two major PACS vendors. He has now made it back safely from the dark side and is sharing his observations. 

His healthcare consulting services for end users include PACS optimization services, system upgrade and proposal reviews, contract reviews, and other areas. The PACSMan is also working with imaging and IT vendors to develop market-focused messaging as well as sales training programs. He can be reached at [email protected] or by phone at 407-359-0191.

The comments and observations expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of AuntMinnie.com.  

 

 

 

Page 1 of 1205
Next Page