Almost one-third of radiologists' ED services uncompensated

By Kate Madden Yee, staff writer
December 12, 2013

Almost a third of services provided by radiologists to emergency department (ED) patients are uncompensated, according to researchers from the American College of Radiology's (ACR) Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute.

These unpaid services correspond to $2,483 per month of lost income per radiologist -- which could affect patient access to care, noted Dr. Richard Duszak Jr., chief medical officer of the institute, who presented the findings at last week's RSNA meeting

"The frequency and magnitude of uncompensated imaging services in the ED has not been rigorously studied," Duszak said. "Given the continued rise in ED services overall and the disproportionate growth of imaging in the ED compared with other sites, the potential workflow and financial impact of uncompensated care on radiology departments and practices could be substantial."

Dr. Richard Duszak Jr.
Dr. Richard Duszak Jr.

Emergency department imaging use has increased, despite a decline in imaging overall, Duszak told session attendees. Also, many clinical services provided in the emergency department are not reimbursed.

"Not long ago, imaging underwent a period of dramatic growth," he said. "But utilization stabilized by 2006 and is now in overall decline -- with the notable exception of the emergency department setting. And some reports show that as much as 79.4% of clinical services provided in the ED are uncompensated."

Duszak and colleagues investigated the frequency and magnitude of uncompensated services provided by radiologists in the ED setting, using billing claims from 2,935 radiologists in 40 states between January 2009 and December 2012. The data came from Zotec Partners, a large, national radiology billing company.

The researchers identified 18,475,491 professional services performed in the ED setting. They focused their analysis on 133 of all reported 830 category I CPT and Healthcare Common Procedure Coding System (HCPCS) codes (which made up 99% of all rendered services). Duszak's group excluded codes that were not valued through the Resource-Based Relative Value Scale (RBRVS) process.

Of the radiologists included in the study, 96.6% delivered care to emergency department patients that was not reimbursed; they received no payment at all for 28.4% of services rendered.

The most frequently provided services were interpretation of the following exams:

  • One-view chest x-ray
  • Two-view chest x-ray
  • Noncontrast brain CT
  • Contrast abdomen/pelvis CT
  • Noncontrast abdomen/pelvis CT

The most frequently used modalities were radiography (58.3%), CT (31.2%), and ultrasound (8.8%), Duszak and colleagues found. Of all uncompensated services, 52.3% were provided to uninsured patients and 47.7% to insured patients (which were not covered because of insurer denial or patient nonpayment of deductible).

How, exactly, could radiology departments and practices be affected by radiologists not getting paid for ED services? In a number of ways, according to Duszak: It could create substantial disincentives for radiologists to prioritize emergency department work, and hospitals with higher ED volumes sending out requests for bids could encounter resistance.

"I personally don't think this will ever get to the point where radiology practices say, 'We don't do ED work,' but it could result in misaligned incentives for radiologists to provide timely services to sicker patients," he told

Rapid growth of advanced imaging use is over, study finds
CHICAGO - Nationwide Medicare data show that rapid growth in the use of advanced imaging in the U.S. has stopped, according to a presentation at RSNA...
Study shows decline in inpatient imaging utilization
CHICAGO - If the experience of Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston is any indication, inpatient imaging utilization dropped after 2009 following two...
Emergency docs want decision support to tackle CT overuse
Generating roughly one-third of all CT scans, the emergency department would seem a key target for imaging decision-support software. And emergency physicians...
Appropriateness training may not lead to proper CTPA use
Providing appropriateness training to emergency department doctors for ordering CT pulmonary angiography (CTPA) exams doesn't necessarily reduce inappropriate...
Emergency radiology elective educates on imaging use
A short emergency radiology elective increases second-year medical students' understanding of appropriate imaging use and the effects of radiation exposure...

Copyright © 2013

Last Updated np 12/12/2013 10:08:20 AM

10 comments so far ...
12/17/2013 11:20:55 AM
I think that's why many are leaving and starting a mobile radiology practice

12/17/2013 1:08:52 PM
Jackie Treehorn
Vendor alert!

12/17/2013 1:47:00 PM
Studycast is the solution to all radiology problems:) 

12/18/2013 12:09:34 PM
Studycast helped me add 2" to my tool.
Thanks Studycast!

12/18/2013 3:40:32 PM
Quote from TarverForPresident

Studycast helped me add 2" to my tool.

Thanks Studycast!

Studycast will throw in the 2nd one free!!!  Just pay separate postage and handling!!!